Beginning Proficiency: Provide simplified versions of the four Talking Points questions with visuals, gestures, or key vocabulary lists in both English and students’ home languages. Provide students with simple sentence starters (e.g., “I believe…,” “I notice…”) in both languages. Invite them to communicate their ideas using a mix of spoken English, familiar home-language words, gestures, or quick sketches to make their meaning clear. Pair students with supportive peers who can help translate or clarify concepts during discussion.