Beginning Proficiency: Provide visual conversation cards that include both pictures and key vocabulary in English and the home language. Pre-teach essential discussion phrases and provide a visual timer to help students pace their sharing. Write discussion prompts clearly on the board in simple English with translations when possible. Give students conversation frames (e.g., “I think…,” “I see…”) in both languages, and encourage them to use gestures, drawings, or their home language alongside English to express their ideas. Strategically pair partners so that students who share a home language can initially practice the structure together before mixing with English-dominant peers.