Instructional Strategy

Britannica Education logo in blue square

INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGY

Idea Funnel

Grade:

3-5, 6-8, 9-12, UNIV

Type:

Organize Thinking
/ Develop Language (MLL)
20-30

Minutes

When:

Before reading

Materials:

Drawing supplies, Idea Funnel graphic organizer, poster paper, whiteboard or display, writing utensil
Chat bubble with list icon in green on white background

Description

Colorful funnels floating on light blue background.
© MicroStockHub—iStock / Getty Images Plus/Getty Images
The Idea Funnel strategy guides students in systematically brainstorming and refining ideas into a focused concept or plan. It fosters critical thinking, collaboration, and decision-making skills and adapts well to different group sizes and learning stages.
Curved arrows forming square in orange on white background

Procedure

1
Provide each student or group with an Idea Funnel graphic organizer. Explain the purpose of the organizer to students, emphasizing that it will support them through the process of brainstorming, discussing, organizing, and refining their ideas into a more focused concept or plan.
2
Ask students to independently brainstorm as many ideas as possible related to a given or chosen topic. Emphasize that there are no wrong answers at this stage and that quantity is key—no idea is too small.
3
Invite students to work in pairs or small groups to share, discuss, and expand on their ideas. Encourage students to share their thoughts, ask questions, and add new ideas based on their discussions.
4
Ask students to group their brainstormed ideas into similar themes or categories, by either physically moving ideas around on the organizer or listing them under thematic headers. Encourage students to look for patterns, overlaps, and connections among their ideas, which might help in merging, refining, or eliminating concepts.
5
Guide students to evaluate their grouped ideas and eliminate those that are less feasible, less impactful, or not aligned with the task’s objectives. To support students in this process, offer guiding questions to help them think critically about each idea’s viability and suitability.
a)
How directly does this idea address the project’s objectives or solve the problem?
b)
What resources are required for this idea, and are they accessible?
c)
Which idea could have the greatest impact, and why?
d)
What are the strengths and weaknesses of your top ideas?
e)
Which idea excites you the most, and why?
6
Encourage students to continue narrowing down their choices until only one idea remains. This should be the idea they believe is the most executable, most impactful, and best aligned with the task objective or desired outcomes.
7
Ask students to prepare either a brief oral presentation or written summary explaining their idea choice, why they chose it, and how it aligns with the learning objectives or desired outcomes. Emphasize that the summary should also reflect on the decision-making process and the criteria used to make their final selection.
Expanding arrows icon in white on purple background

Differentiation

Idea Evaluation Checklist: As students narrow down their ideas using the graphic organizer, provide them with an evaluation criteria checklist to support their list refinement. A checklist offers a structured method for assessing and refining ideas, promoting independent and critical thinking, and ensuring that the decision-making process is consistent and thorough.
Counterargument Development: Encourage students to develop counterarguments to their ideas after grouping them but before refining them. By identifying and assessing potential weaknesses, students can anticipate challenges and consider alternative perspectives. This enhances their critical thinking and problem-solving skills, leading to more robust and defensible ideas through proactive reflection.

Multilingual Learning Support

Beginning Proficiency: Support initial brainstorming by allowing students to generate ideas in their home language first. Provide a bilingual vocabulary bank relevant to the topic and simple organizational phrases in both languages. Create a modified Idea Funnel template with visual cues and bilingual labels for each section. During pair/group discussions, pair students with same-language peers initially to build confidence in idea sharing. Provide basic sentence frames in both languages to help students explain their ideas and choices (e.g., “My idea is…” / “I chose this because…”). Support students in gradually translating their key ideas into English with assistance.
Intermediate Proficiency: Enhance idea development and evaluation by providing bilingual academic vocabulary and transition phrases for organizing and comparing ideas. Guide students to record ideas in both languages, encouraging increasing use of English while maintaining home language support. During group discussions, provide structured bilingual prompts for evaluating and refining ideas. Support students in expressing more complex reasoning for their choices using English, with home language clarification when needed. Create evaluation guides with key criteria in both languages to help students assess their ideas systematically.
Advanced Proficiency: Begin brainstorming in either language, and then guide students to express ideas in academic English using discipline-specific vocabulary (e.g., moving from “it gets bigger” to “it expands exponentially”). For younger students, focus on using precise English vocabulary while letting them check understanding in their home language. For older students, support them in using complex English phrases to evaluate ideas (e.g., “This idea is more viable because…”). During group discussions, have students explain their thinking using sophisticated transitions and comparison language (e.g., “While both ideas address the problem, this approach is more efficient because…”). When students encounter concepts that are difficult to express in English, encourage them to explain the idea in their home language first, and then work together to find the most accurate academic English expression.
Overlapping documents icon in light blue on white background

Variations

Reverse Idea Funnel: Following the initial narrowing of ideas, students expand these ideas creatively through “what-if” scenarios or imaginative variations to explore broader applications and implications of their refined concepts. By reimagining their ideas in different contexts or with altered constraints, students enhance their problem-solving and creative-thinking skills.
© Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. All rights reserved.